
Was overturning the elections a real danger?
In the run-up to the recent midterm elections, Oaklandsocialist warned that there was a genuine danger that Trump could try to overturn the election results, possibly by force, and that if he did – or even seriously tried to – that the United States would have crossed a Rubicon. We pointed to several dangers:
First was Trump’s attempts to seize and distort the process of mail-in voting. There were also dangers:
- a vast increase in funding for ICE and CBP, linked with the threat of mobilizing them to repress voters at the polling places
- refusal to accept vote counts by the 2020 conspiracists who populate many election boards across the country
- even the possibility that Trump could mobilize the National Guard to seize voting machines. He had even said in January of this year that he regretted not having done so in 2020. None of these threats materialized.
As far as defending mail-in voting, the Democrats’ main line of defense was going to the courts. Oaklandsocialist warned that the court system – the Supreme Court especially – could not be relied upon. Yet in the end, Trump lost every single court case on the issue, including at the Supreme Court level.
What happened? Were our warnings out of touch with reality?

J. Michael Luttig. He warned of the threat also.
In the first place, it wasn’t just Oaklandsocialist. Even such figures as the prominent conservative retired federal judge J. Michael Luttig was issuing similar warnings.
As far as the threat to mail-in voting: The typically bumbling Trump administration waited too long to get started in undermining that process. Republican election officials across the country opposed the administration’s new regulations because it was too late to comply. It would have caused chaos. So the Trump Six on the Supreme Court (Alito, Roberts, Thomas, Barrett, Kavanaugh and Gorsuch) could not swallow what Trump was trying to do. Given a longer lead time for the 2028 elections, however, those postal regulations are a genuine threat.
Regarding the other threats, Oaklandsocialist qualified our warnings by pointing out that if the vote was so overwhelming against the Republicans, that could ward off those other threats. That was part of what happened, and in fact on the day before the elections Oaklandsocialist tentatively recognized that as being the more likely outcome.
However, there seems to have been another factor: I think that Trump got a real scare by the legal cases against him, especially the documents case in Florida and, even more so, the case that special prosecutor Jack Smith was preparing in Washington DC. He was saved in the Mar-a-Lago documents case partly by the fact that he had a Trump sycophant judge, Aileen Cannon. In both cases Trump was also saved by Biden’s extremely weak attorney general, Merrick Garland. Garland delayed appointing a special prosecutor for so long that when the cases finally got under way the looming 2024 election put them to a halt.
Some voices did say that the US’s “democratic institutions” would be able to withstand Trump’s attacks. Another way of interpreting that is that the majority of the US capitalist class opposed Trump’s drive to overturn capitalism’s democratic form of rule. The capitalists have no need to overturn that form of rule, and what’s more without it they cannot restrain Trump’s more destabilizing policies such as his tariffs and his alliance with Putin and now increasingly with Xi also.
So, yes, there was less of an immediate threat to the democratic form of rule than Oaklandsocialist’s articles estimated. Our articles were not completely wrong, but their balance was off. The reason for that lies mainly in the fact that the situation we face is without precedent in US history, and we are struggling to find our way. The dangers still lie there, however.

Was overturning the elections a real danger?
Discover more from Oakland Socialist
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Categories: politics, Trump, Uncategorized, United States
